Texas judge declines to close Camp Mystic but bars construction on campus hit by flooding

In a recent ruling, a Texas judge denied a request to permanently shut down Camp Mystic, the site of last year’s deadly July 4 floods in the Texas Hill Country. However, the judge imposed a temporary ban on modifying or building on the specific area where the disaster occurred. The decision came after a hearing in Travis County, where Will and CiCi Steward, parents of Cecilia “Cile” Steward, who died during the incident, pressed for legal action against the camp’s operators.

Legal Proceedings and Court Order

State District Judge Maya Guerra Gamble reviewed evidence in a crowded courtroom, considering a temporary restraining order and injunction sought by the Stewards. The judge’s order prevents any changes to the structures used by campers during the July 4 floods, including the commissary, rec hall, and main office on the Guadalupe River grounds. While these areas remain off-limits, other parts of the campus may continue construction.

“This application for injunctive relief seeks to preserve the status quo and protect material evidence bearing on how and why Cile Steward lost her life while entrusted to Defendants’ care,” the Stewards’ filing stated.

Flood Tragedy and Casualties

The July 4 floods in Kerr County claimed 25 lives, including girls, counselors, and the camp’s owner. Cile’s body has yet to be found, and over 130 people in the region perished in the disaster. The Stewards had argued that ongoing construction and remodeling at the site risked destroying critical evidence, even as search efforts for their daughter continue.

Testimony and Safety Measures

Edward Eastland, the camp’s director at the time of the flood, testified in defense. He acknowledged that some buildings had been repaired but noted that the cabins lacked walkie-talkies and that security cameras were not monitored during the night. Meanwhile, Camp Mystic highlighted its safety upgrades, such as flood monitoring units, in its December announcement of reopening plans.

Legal Challenges and Reactions

Brad Beckworth, the Stewards’ attorney, emphasized the court’s role in safeguarding evidence. “The Guadalupe River side of Camp Mystic will not be reopening anytime soon until we complete the evidentiary process leading to trial,” he said. Mikal Watts, representing the camp and the Eastland family, praised the ruling, stating that the Guadalupe grounds’ evidence would be preserved as agreed. He added that the Cypress Lake location, now considered independent, is compliant with new state safety laws.

Broader Legal Context

Earlier this week, families of nine flood victims sued the state, alleging failure to enforce evacuation requirements. Additionally, Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick urged the Department of State Health Services to withhold a license for Camp Mystic until legislative investigations conclude. The camp responded by affirming its Cypress Lake site meets all updated safety standards.

With the ruling in place, the legal battle over Camp Mystic’s operations continues, balancing the need for safety improvements against the preservation of evidence from the tragic event.